スキップしてメイン コンテンツに移動

注目

ヴェイダー卿がFOを率いていたら理想

機敏で機動的な帝国は皇帝の目標だった。 帝国の肥大化は負担となり、国家運営、安全保障、体制維持、全てにおいて疲弊していたのだ。 反乱分子をもっと早いうちに叩ければ、後々あらゆる労力とコストが低下していたに違いない。 結局、皇帝の死により体制は崩壊する。独裁体制の限界だ。 ヴェイダー卿は皇帝に献身していたが、帝国の在り方に懸念を抱いていたと思われる。つまらない政治的束縛に縛られず、内部を横断して迅速な行動を認められる暗黒卿だったが、不十分であった。帝国の構造的欠陥、太り過ぎていて、力強いが鈍いのだ。 おそらく帝国が資源と労力、コストを無限に使える発想に端を発する。 何の制限も設けなかったせいで、不効率を招く温床になっていたのだ。 限りある資源を最小限に使う発想は帝国になかったのだ。 すなわち特殊作戦を主体にした非国家主体である。 そもそも反乱分子をもっと早いうちに叩ければ、後々あらゆる労力とコストが低下していた。その反省である。何より低コストだから、軽く機敏で機動的だ。 もしヴェイダー卿が生きていたら、率いさせたかった。スノークはヴェイダー卿を意識していた。ヴェイダーと同じように、カイロレンにやらせたかったのだ。 しかしカイロレンは力不足であり、ヴェイダーに匹敵しない。 ヴェイダーほどのフォース感応者でないのだ。 「お前はヴェイダーではない、マスクを被った子供よ」 特殊作戦をカイロレンにやらせて、あらゆるコストを低下させるスノークの構想は、思っていた程成功しなかった。 アナキンはクローン戦争で共和国軍を日々 指揮しており鍛えられていたが、ベンソロの場合、帝国崩壊後の平時である。 アナキンと違い、ベンソロは経験不足だったのだ。 いくら同じ血が流れていても、環境が左右する。 また、カイロレンはそもそも当たり前のように特殊作戦を体験していたが、特殊作戦の恩恵が分からなかった。当然だ、帝国を体験しなかったから。 帝国の不満、構造的欠陥を意識して初めて、ファーストオーダーの意味が理解できる。プライド元帥などの経験豊かな人材が当てはまる。 これはカイロレン以外の人員にも言える事で、若い人材を好むファーストオーダー特有の問題である。 いかに帝国が疲弊したか経験していなかったから、彼らは銀河全域への侵攻作戦のリスクを想定できなかった。 見方を変えれば、操りやすい人員の集まりなのである...

Emergency powers may have been Yoda's invention

A refresher on the Clone Wars plan


The Emperor, who brought the Clone Wars to an end, uncovers the fact that the Jedi were planning the battle and that they were controlling the war situation behind the scenes by manipulating both allies and enemies.


Most of the senators accept the Emperor's explanation and understand the scenario that the Jedi intended to make Palpatine a dictator and take over.


For this reason, it is convenient to argue that emergency powers were forcibly granted.

In fact, the establishment of emergency powers was essentially a forced vote.

The Senate, which had struggled to such an extent with the creation of a republican army and the possession of a regular army, suddenly approved the establishment of emergency powers in the face of security threats.


This weakness of democracy seemed to have come as a surprise to Palpatine, and he was hesitant about borrowing this much authority. He even made it clear that he would be happy to give it back when the crisis was over. (No one expected Palpatine to become a dictator)



Even before the Emergency Powers were established, Palpatine was assisted by Yoda's advice. Yoda's experienced advice was invaluable in dealing with the Senate's most complex challenges.

For many years, Yoda has been concerned about the senate's corruption and depravity, and has warned that he is unable to prepare for emergencies.


How should the Senate act in times of emergency? Yoda suggests that there is an option called emergency powers.

He temporarily borrows the power held by the Senate as prerogative, bypassing parliamentary resolutions and creating a swift and powerful top-down system. He can save slow and dull resolutions and parliamentary approvals.


When Lord Sidious hears of this method, he is very pleased.

In this case, you can fool the Senate by stating that you are only borrowing it temporarily and that you will be happy to return it later. If the crisis situation is prolonged after it is established, power will legally be concentrated in Palpatine's hands all at once.


Yoda proposed emergency powers, but he never thought they would actually pass. In other words, he did not imagine that the republic would face a crisis situation.

He also praises Palpatine's promise to Congress to return emergency powers. I felt relieved because it was a temporary exercise. He promises to quickly end the Clone Wars.



However, the end of the war was delayed considerably, and the day when prerogative powers were returned never came. The Senate will be eviscerated and an abnormal dictatorship will be established.

Yoda regretted his twisted use of emergency powers. He probably told everyone he shouldn't have told Palpatine about emergency powers. (He told the Sith Lord directly)

Yoda could not imagine a situation where emergency powers would not be returned. He was made to break his promise to the emperor.

(Mace and his friends also believed in the return of prerogatives, right? Anakin had doubts.)


If Yoda or the Council insisted on imposing emergency powers in the Senate, it would confirm the scenario that the Jedi orchestrated the war.

人気の投稿